Call Now

Call Now

Call Now


What Happens If The Supreme Court Takes My Case?

What Happens If The Supreme Court Takes My Case?

Very few cases go directly to the Indiana Supreme Court (ISC) as a matter of right.1 Most cases wind up in the ISC as a matter of discretion. The way this occurs is a party to a Court of Appeals’ (COA) decision (Indiana’s intermediate appellate court) seeks transfer. The ISC must accept the case. When it does so, it vacates the COA’s decision. This blog explores what the ISC may do on transfer and highlights a new case the reflects a change in the way the ISC has operated in the past given the addition of new Justices in the last several years.

If the Supreme Court grants transfer, it normally requests the parties’ counsel to orally argue the merits of the case before its five Justices. However, it can merely decide the case and issue an opinion. In fact, because it is the Supreme Court, it can take any approach it wishes to a case it accepts on transfer as it deems appropriate. However, the ISC is steeped in tradition and ordinarily handles cases in routine ways.

That said, assuming there is an oral argument, the ISC may ultimately affirm the COA in whole or part, reverse the COA and affirm the trial court, or in cases where there are conflicting COA decisions, invalidate an entire line of caselaw. If the ISC reverses the COA, then it means the trial court’s decision may be reversed or affirmed depending on how the COA ruled. These are the customary ways the ISC handles and decides cases.

The recent case of Harris v. State2 illustrates a newer style the ISC has taken in deciding how to handle the laws before it based on different facts that may be presented in each case. In Harris, after granting transfer, the ISC heard oral arguments from the parties. Then, after the case, its’ Justices held a conference to discuss the points raised in oral argument. In this conference, the ISC determined that it should not have assumed jurisdiction over the appeal and reinstated the Indiana Court of Appeals’ decision.3

Ultimately, to promote stability and uniformity in the law, the ISC signaled that in certain cases that appear to merit transfer, the better way to serve the needs of the litigants that come before it is to vacate its jurisdiction over a case correctly decided by the COA. This means that Hoosiers and those litigating in the Indiana legal system should know that the legal system has a series of checks and balance on the law at the highest levels. Only when a case has such unique facts and the law is not correctly being applied to them or is outdated, will the ISC decide a case on the merits. This blog was written by Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. advocates who handles appeals from all final orders from Indiana trial courts. This blog is written for general educational purposes; it not legal advice or a solicitation for services. It is an advertisement.

  1. Indiana Rule of Appellate Procedure 4.
  2. 19S-PC-00-529.
  3. Harris v. State, 131 N.E.3d 195 (Ind.Ct.App.2009).

We Listen & Care

Proven & experienced attorneys successfully advocating & resolving complex cases for over 25 years

Quick Contact

Need to talk now? Fill out the quick form below and we will contact you directly.
Blog Categories

Get In Touch

We're available to answer your questions 24/7.

Contact Us

Please fill out the form below and we will be in touch with you shortly.

Dixon & Moseley, P.C., is a law firm located in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve clients in six core practice areas: family lawappellate practicefirearms lawgeneral practicepersonal injury and criminal law.

Call Now

Copyright © 2024 Ciyou & Dixon, P.C., Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. This Site does not provide legal advice; please review the disclaimer for other limitations. Privacy Policy

Based in Indianapolis and founded in 1995, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. is a niche law firm focused on successfully dealing with the complexities of divorce, high-conflict child custody and family law. Known for their ability to solve extremely complex situations with high quality work and responsiveness, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. will guide you every step of the way. The family law attorneys at Dixon & Moseley, P.C. will help you precisely identify your objectives and the means to reach your desired result. Life is uncertain. Be certain of your counsel. Indianapolis Divorce Attorneys, Dixon & Moseley, P.C.

Indianapolis Divorce Attorneys, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. of Indianapolis, Indiana, offers legal services for Indianapolis, Zionsville, Noblesville, Carmel, Avon, Anderson, Danville, Greenwood, Brownsburg, Geist, Fortville, McCordsville, Muncie, Greenfield, Westfield, Fort Wayne, Fishers, Bloomington, Lafayette, Marion County, Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Allen County, Delaware County, Morgan County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Vigo County, Johnson County, Hancock County, and Tippecanoe County, Indiana.