Call Now

Call Now

Call Now


Custody Modification Evidence

Custody Modification: What Evidence Can Be Introduced

In family law matters, custody will be determined as an initial matter to a divorce or paternity proceeding1 or can be later modified once it has been established2. There are several factors that determine physical and legal custody, with the best interest of the child(ren) being paramount.

However, once custody is established, can custody be changed? The answer generally is yes; however, there are limitations to changing or modifying custody. For example, if an initial custody determination is made and Father is granted physical custody, Mother may file to modify physical custody to her.

To achieve this, she would need to file a motion to modify physical custody and show to the Court that there has been both a substantial change in circumstances, usually in one of the initial physical custody determination factors (for example, the age and sex of the child or the child’s adjustment to the child’s school) and modification is in the best interests of the child.

When a motion to modify custody is filed and a hearing is held on this motion, there is a limit to the evidence the parties can present. The threshold issue in modification is a change in circumstances since the last order of the court. Therefore the time limitation for evidence and testimony is the date of the initial custody determination or most recent custody modification.
Generally, evidence and information from before to the last order on custody cannot be submitted at the new hearing. However, as with most rules, there are exceptions to the rule.

So, if in the example above, Mother files to modify custody, she can only present evidence to support her desired change in custody back to the time when Father was initially granted custody. If Father had a drug conviction before the initial custody determination, it is not proper evidence for custody modification, because it does not show a substantial change in circumstances. His conviction was prior to the last custody order. This is perhaps an over simplification of the rule, and the court could allow testimony upon same under the exception.

The specific language of the rule is that “the court shall not hear evidence on a matter occurring before the last custody proceeding between the parties unless the matter relates to a change in the factors relating to the best interests of the child…”3. Therefore, whether it has been one (1) year or ten (10) years, the time frame of permissible evidence in a custody modification goes back only to the last custody proceeding.

Understanding this rule can help narrow the focus of a custody modification. While history for both parties is helpful in putting custody modification into context and determining the best interests of the child, realizing there is a limitation to evidence that can be introduced makes the process easier. Do not be frustrated if there is a past issue that cannot be brought up. Instead, discuss with your counsel what has changed and look to the proper time frame to make the strongest case.

We hope that this blog has been helpful in exploring proper evidence in a custody modification matter and the time limitations on same. Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. practices throughout the state of Indiana. This blog post was written by Attorney, Jessica Keyes.

  1. See Ind. Code §31-17-2-8 and §31-14-13-2
  2. See Ind. Code §31-17-2-21 and §31-14-13-6
  3. Ind. Code §31-17-2-21

We Listen & Care

Proven & experienced attorneys successfully advocating & resolving complex cases for over 25 years

Quick Contact

Need to talk now? Fill out the quick form below and we will contact you directly.
Blog Categories

Get In Touch

We're available to answer your questions 24/7.

Contact Us

Please fill out the form below and we will be in touch with you shortly.

Dixon & Moseley, P.C., is a law firm located in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve clients in six core practice areas: family lawappellate practicefirearms lawgeneral practicepersonal injury and criminal law.

Call Now

Copyright © 2024 Ciyou & Dixon, P.C., Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. This Site does not provide legal advice; please review the disclaimer for other limitations. Privacy Policy

Based in Indianapolis and founded in 1995, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. is a niche law firm focused on successfully dealing with the complexities of divorce, high-conflict child custody and family law. Known for their ability to solve extremely complex situations with high quality work and responsiveness, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. will guide you every step of the way. The family law attorneys at Dixon & Moseley, P.C. will help you precisely identify your objectives and the means to reach your desired result. Life is uncertain. Be certain of your counsel. Indianapolis Divorce Attorneys, Dixon & Moseley, P.C.

Indianapolis Divorce Attorneys, Dixon & Moseley, P.C. of Indianapolis, Indiana, offers legal services for Indianapolis, Zionsville, Noblesville, Carmel, Avon, Anderson, Danville, Greenwood, Brownsburg, Geist, Fortville, McCordsville, Muncie, Greenfield, Westfield, Fort Wayne, Fishers, Bloomington, Lafayette, Marion County, Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Allen County, Delaware County, Morgan County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Vigo County, Johnson County, Hancock County, and Tippecanoe County, Indiana.